⚡ Quick Summary
This study investigates the extent to which Digital Health Technologies (DHTs) can align with the principles of Responsible Innovation in Health (RIH). It identifies key enablers and constraints in the development and utilization of responsible DHTs within health organizations.
🔍 Key Details
- 📊 Participants: 29 stakeholders from a large Canadian academic health center
- 🧩 Methodology: Semi-structured interviews and thematic analysis
- ⚙️ Framework: Responsible Innovation in Health (RIH)
- 🏆 Focus: Development, procurement, and utilization of DHTs
🔑 Key Takeaways
- 🌱 Organizational culture significantly influences the adoption of RIH principles.
- 💰 Resource availability (material, financial, and expertise) is crucial for responsible DHT development.
- 🔍 Health Technology Assessment (HTA) practices need to evolve to include broader dimensions beyond effectiveness and costs.
- 📜 Regulatory frameworks play a vital role in the approval and use of DHTs.
- 📈 Market dynamics, including venture capital, impact innovation policies at federal and provincial levels.
- 🤝 Collaboration among stakeholders is essential for integrating RIH principles into health systems.
- 🔄 Continuous evaluation of DHTs is necessary to ensure alignment with societal values.
- 🌍 Insights can guide scholars, practitioners, and policymakers in fostering responsible innovation.
📚 Background
The rapid expansion of Digital Health Technologies (DHTs) during the COVID-19 pandemic has raised important questions regarding their impact on health systems. As societies strive for more equitable and sustainable healthcare, the concept of Responsible Innovation in Health (RIH) has gained traction. RIH emphasizes the need to align innovation processes and outcomes with societal values, making it a critical area of focus for researchers and policymakers alike.
🗒️ Study
This research was conducted through semi-structured interviews with 29 stakeholders involved in the development, procurement, and utilization of DHTs at a prominent Canadian academic health center. The study aimed to uncover the enablers and constraints that affect the integration of RIH principles in health organizations, employing a mixed deductive-inductive thematic analysis based on the RIH framework.
📈 Results
The findings reveal that the successful incorporation of RIH principles into DHTs is largely contingent upon several organizational and systemic factors. Key elements include the presence of a supportive organizational culture, adequate resources, the evolution of HTA practices, comprehensive regulatory frameworks, and the influence of market dynamics on innovation policies.
🌍 Impact and Implications
The insights from this study are pivotal for health organizations aiming to develop and utilize responsible DHTs. By understanding the enablers and constraints identified, stakeholders can create conditions that foster the integration of RIH principles, ultimately leading to more equitable and sustainable health systems. This research serves as a valuable resource for scholars, practitioners, and decision-makers in navigating the complexities of digital health innovation.
🔮 Conclusion
This study highlights the importance of aligning Digital Health Technologies with the principles of Responsible Innovation. By addressing the identified enablers and constraints, health organizations can enhance their capacity to implement responsible DHTs, paving the way for improved health outcomes and greater societal alignment. The journey towards responsible innovation in health is ongoing, and continued research and collaboration are essential for success.
💬 Your comments
What are your thoughts on the integration of responsible innovation principles in digital health technologies? We invite you to share your insights and engage in a discussion! 💬 Leave your comments below or connect with us on social media:
To What Extent Can Digital Health Technologies Comply With the Principles of Responsible Innovation? Practice-and Policy-Oriented Research Insights Regarding an Organisational and Systemic Issue.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Digital health technologies (DHTs) have expanded exponentially since the COVID-19 crisis and have prompted questions about their impact across all levels of health systems. Because health organisations and systems play a central role in the success or failure of the transition to more equitable and sustainable societies, the concept of Responsible Innovation in Health (RIH), focused on aligning the processes and outcomes of innovation with societal values, is gaining interest in research, policy, and practice. This study aims to explore enablers and constraints to the development, procurement and/or utilisation of responsible DHTs in health organisations.
METHODS: Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 29 stakeholders concerned with the development, procurement, and/or utilisation of DHTs in a large Canadian academic health centre. Data were thematically analysed through a mixed deductive-inductive process using the RIH framework.
RESULTS: Our findings highlight that the consideration of RIH principles in the development, procurement, and/or utilisation of DHTs depends mainly on organisational and systemic factors and conditions, namely: (1) the presence of an organisational culture that promotes RIH in its innovation-related practices and processes; (2) availability of material and financial resources as well as expertise in certain fields (eg, environmental sustainability); (3) the evolution of health technology assessment (HTA) practices to include other dimensions beyond effectiveness, safety, and costs; (4) the scope of the regulatory and legal frameworks that govern the approval and use of DHTs; and (5) the role of the market (eg, venture capital) in the design of federal and provincial innovation policies.
CONCLUSION: This study provides insights on practice, policy, and political issues that health organisations may face in the development, procurement, and/or utilisation of responsible DHTs. It can help scholars, practitioners, decision-makers, and industry to create the conditions for a better integration of RIH principles into health organisations and systems.
Author: [‘Alami H’, ‘Lehoux P’, ‘E Shaw S’, ‘Niang M’, ‘Malas K’, ‘Fortin JP’]
Journal: Int J Health Policy Manag
Citation: Alami H, et al. To What Extent Can Digital Health Technologies Comply With the Principles of Responsible Innovation? Practice-and Policy-Oriented Research Insights Regarding an Organisational and Systemic Issue. To What Extent Can Digital Health Technologies Comply With the Principles of Responsible Innovation? Practice-and Policy-Oriented Research Insights Regarding an Organisational and Systemic Issue. 2024; 13:8061. doi: 10.34172/ijhpm.8061